Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Harry Dang's avatar

Collison's caveat is the whole argument, and it is doing more work than the headline. "It all depends on agents staying on the consumer's side" is not a footnote — it is the condition on which the entire quality subsidy rests. If the agent is paid by the buyer, it researches every purchase and the coupon, the checkout upsell and the forgotten subscription stop working. But if the agent is paid by the seller, or by the platform, the same machinery becomes the most effective distribution trick ever built, because it now arrives with the authority of a personal advisor. That is why Knoop's three layers matter more than the headline: visibility in training, published evaluation scores, installable skills. Quality is not enough on its own — the agent has to be able to find it and verify it, which means the new distribution is not shelf space but legibility to machines. Your own data section makes the case that this is already happening: Vercel's network is 58% bot traffic, and Linear's MCP usage grew 20x in a year. The agents are already the customer. My question is about the information layer Collison says will become far more valuable: who certifies it? If quality information is the new advertising, the winners are not just the best products but the owners of the trusted score — the eval, the review, the metric layer. Pinterest's Metrics Board points the same way inside companies. So the investment question is not whether agents reward quality, but who owns the referee.

Mohamed F. Ahmed's avatar

If an agent is doing the comparison shopping instead of a human, "quality" probably stops meaning a slick checkout flow and starts meaning clean structured data, predictable pricing, and documented edge cases an agent can actually parse. Six months from now the companies ahead might be the ones that look boring to a human but read perfectly to a machine. Has anyone seen early data on what agents actually weight when picking between near-identical products?

1 more comment...

Ready for more?